A heartwarming Mother’s Day picture featuring Kate Middleton and her three children has stirred a storm of controversy.

The image, released by Kensington Palace, marks Kate’s first public appearance since undergoing abdominal surgery in January.

However, it has now been withdrawn by major foreign picture agencies, including Reuters, AP, Getty, and AFP, citing potential digital manipulation.

While Kensington Palace stands by the authenticity of the photo, concerns over potential alterations have prompted its removal from circulation.

AP issued an alert requesting the removal of the image, stating that upon closer inspection, it appeared to have been manipulated. Similar demands were echoed by other agencies, citing editorial reasons.

Editorial issue

AFP issued a directive for the immediate withdrawal of the photo, indicating an editorial issue.

Reuters also stated that the picture was being pulled following a post-publication review.

The move comes amid growing concerns within the news industry regarding the manipulation of photographs using AI technology, although specific details regarding the alterations remain unclear.

Notably, observers pointed out apparent digital alterations in the image, including discrepancies in Princess Charlotte’s wrist and clothing, as well as anomalies in the background scenery.

Photoshop fail

This controversy follows previous scrutiny over the Wales family’s Christmas card, which was criticised for a supposed “Photoshop fail.”

Kensington Palace has refrained from commenting on the matter, further fueling speculation surrounding the princess’s health.

The photo, originally shared on social media channels, was reportedly taken by Prince William earlier in the week at their Windsor home.

Amidst the controversy, the absence of significant updates regarding Kate’s condition from Kensington Palace has drawn criticism.

No comment from Kensington Palace tonight after at least 3 international pictures agencies refuse to distribute this morning’s photo of Kate and her children. Some of them (@AP ) have claimed “the source [the palace] has manipulated the image”. pic.twitter.com/ppOwDtPr9P

— Chris Ship (@chrisshipitv) March 10, 2024