News

Trump faces setback as appeals court rejects immunity claim

Add Ticker News on Google
Biden, Trump unpopularity buoys third party hopes for 2024 US ...

A federal appeals court ruled that Trump does not enjoy immunity from charges related to his alleged efforts to overturn the 2020 election results.

This ruling takes him one step closer to facing an unprecedented criminal trial.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit firmly rejected Trump’s assertion that he cannot be prosecuted because the allegations stem from his official duties as president.

“We cannot accept that the office of the Presidency places its former occupants above the law for all time thereafter,” the unanimous panel emphasized.

Executive immunity

The court further asserted that any executive immunity that might have protected Trump from criminal charges while in office “no longer shields him from prosecution.”

Trump has vowed to appeal the decision, continuing his effort to avoid a trial that could potentially charge him with undermining American democracy and the peaceful transfer of power. Simultaneously, he remains the frontrunner for the Republican presidential nomination.

Bedrock of republic

A spokesperson for Trump’s campaign, Steven Cheung, expressed concern over the ruling, stating that it “threatens the bedrock of our Republic.”

Cheung confirmed that Trump would appeal but did not specify whether the case would be reviewed by the full D.C. Circuit Court or directly taken to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Meanwhile, Special Counsel Jack Smith, who is leading the prosecution, declined to comment on the matter.

The case remains on hold until at least Monday, allowing Trump time to make his appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Trump’s legal team has argued that former presidents should be granted extensive legal protections, making it impossible to prosecute them for official actions unless they have been impeached by the House of Representatives and removed from office by the Senate.

Two impeachments

Notably, Trump faced two impeachments during his presidency, both resulting in acquittal by Senate Republicans.

The recent ruling questioned the broad scope of Trump’s claim, specifically inquiring whether even a president who ordered military operations to eliminate a political opponent could escape prosecution without congressional action.

The panel’s written ruling stated that granting immunity to Trump in this case would grant presidents “unlimited authority to commit crimes that would undermine the essential checks on executive power, such as recognizing and implementing election results.”

Ultimately, the judges found no “functional justification” for extending full protection to former presidents regarding actions tied to their official responsibilities.

Prosecute Biden

Trump has frequently asserted his immunity claim on the campaign trail and social media, suggesting that a future administration led by him could potentially prosecute President Joe Biden if he were to return to the White House.

The indictment brought forth by Special Counsel Smith accuses Trump of using false claims of voter fraud to pressure state lawmakers, Justice Department officials, and then-Vice President Mike Pence into obstructing the certification of the election results.

This indictment is one of four criminal cases Trump currently faces, with two of them alleging interference in the 2020 election.

Up next
Could tax cuts deliver a better deal for hospitality businesses and workers?

Victoria’s hospitality industry is facing growing pressure from rising employment costs, with business operators.

Read the story →

Comments

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Comments are checked before they appear. Keep it civil, and please don't make claims about people you can't back up.

Ticker Today takes a daily view of the world of news, politics and business.With Ahron YoungWhisky & Suits explores law, property finance and business over fine whisky.With Imran Khan and Chris ChristofiThe Founders Method explores practical lessons and systems for entrepreneursWith Jonathan Byrt and Jesse LeeworthyThe Connector explores property and urban growth across Australia and the UK.With Belinda CoateThe Property Playbook delivers research-led insights for property investors.With Tim Graham and Terry RyderState of Hospitality explores the challenges facing Australia's hospitality.With Jeremy KoadlowBuying Power helps young professionals enter property and build lasting wealth.With Victor and Reshmi KumarThe Airport Economist explores global trade, business and economic outlooks.With Tim HarcourtMedia Movers explores the trends shaping Australia's media and global news.With James ManningBroker Business explores strategies to build, grow and sustain a business.With Rex AfrasiabiMoney Matters explores practical financial strategies to build lasting wealth.With Dr Steven EnticottBeyond Education explores the ideas and technology shaping future learning.With Greg CampitelliTicker Air explores the latest aviation news, travel trends and developments.With Ahron YoungEarly Years Dialogue explores the issues shaping Australia's early learning.With Paul MondoMarkets and Machines explores AI, regulation and trends shaping the markets.With Chris BergSocial Intelligence explores how social media and AI transform our daily lives.With Dr Karen SutherlandThe AI Edge explores how artificial intelligence reshapes the world economy.With Brad Gastwirth

More from Ticker

Watch

More in News

View all →