Facebook, Twitter and Google have come under fire yet again as they must choose whether to censor the Taliban as it retakes Afghanistan
In the debate on censorship and civic duty, big tech is encountering a high-stakes question: whether it should censor the Taliban.
Facebook, Twitter and Google currently have bans in place to prevent the Taliban from creating accounts on their platforms.
But as the Taliban takes over Afghanistan, big tech must choose whether to block the country’s official state social media channels.
We went to Afghanistan almost 20 years ago with clear goals: get those who attacked us on September 11, 2001—and make sure al Qaeda could not use Afghanistan as a base from which to attack us again.
We did that—a decade ago.
Our mission was never supposed to be nation building.
Facebook says that it’s likely to take cues from the US government and other global leaders
It still remains unclear whether the US will recognise the Taliban as Afghanistan’s official government.
US President Biden is unlikely to take this route unless the Taliban publicly severs ties from terrorist groups like al-Qaeda.
The Taliban has already promised to protect the rights of minorities and women, but this remains to be seen.
How are Facebook, Google and Twitter handling the situation?
Facebook has said that it will continue to ban content from the Taliban so far as the US continues to classify the group as a dangerous terror organisation. The platform also removes any posts which explicitly praise the group.
Google, which owns Youtube, has banned the Taliban from operating accounts. User content which promotes the Taliban can be flagged for inciting violence or spreading hate speech.
Meanwhile, Twitter doesn’t yet have a specific policy to outline how it will respond to the Taliban other than those generally prohibiting posts that glorify violence.
If big tech gives the Taliban the green pass, concerns are that the group will use the platforms to spread propaganda.
The Taliban has already started trying to effectively re-brand itself, pledging to build an ‘inclusive government’ earlier this week.
It said this new government would protect the rights of women and minorities “within the bounds of sharia law”.
During the Taliban’s occupation of Afghanistan from 1996 to 2001, its interpretation of Sharia laws included stoning or executing women who refused to comply with the regime.
If you censor & advocate violence over objectionable speech you have no moral high ground.
This specific behavior is not limited to the Taliban.
Today in the west we have many cases of people being silenced, arrested or jailed over speech deemed objectionable by the state. https://t.co/aUx3rsVmf5
Would banning the Taliban from social media lead to more harm?
Another major concern is that more aggressive censorship against the Taliban could limit global discourse about affairs in Afghanistan.
Faiza Patel from the Brennan Center for Justice’s Liberty & National Security program raised concerns about entirely censoring the group.
“How does that constrain political discourse on Facebook if you literally cannot talk about the Taliban except to criticise them?”
“I know most of us are probably going to be criticizing the Taliban, but there are obvious objective conversations that you can have about what it means” for Afghanistan.
It remains yet to be seen whether the group will honour its promise of protecting the rights of all Afghans, and what role big tech will have to play moving forward.
Natasha is an Associate Producer at ticker NEWS with a Bachelor of arts from Monash University. She has previously worked at Sky News Australia and Monash University as an Online Content Producer.
In an industry constantly looking towards the future, anniversary re-releases offer a welcome opportunity to celebrate the past.
In an era of nostalgia, anniversary re-releases of classic films like “Star Wars Episode 1: The Phantom Menace,” “Spider-Man 2,” and “Shrek 2” are captivating audiences anew.
From the thrill of podracing to the iconic battles between heroes and villains, these films offer a chance to relive cherished moments on the big screen.
Tobey Maguire’s Spider-Man swings back into action, Shrek and his crew return for another hilarious adventure, and the galaxy far, far away beckons once more.
As fans of all ages flock to theaters, these timeless classics remind us why great storytelling endures, bridging generations and captivating audiences with their magic.
TikTok’s fate in the United States has never been more in doubt.
Congress approved a bill, which President Joe Biden signed into law that gives its Chinese parent company two options: sell it to an approved buyer or see it banned.
But now, the owners of the popular social media app says they’re preparing to challenge the statute in court.
Andy Keiser a Senior Fellow at the National Security Institute, and a Former Senior Advisor for the House Intelligence Committee joins Veronica Dudo to discuss. #IN AMERICA TODAY #featured #business #socialmedia #TikTok #TikTokban #nationalsecurity
New research shows the impact of alcohol on our gut microbiome.
Alcohol affects gut microbes, potentially leading to gut imbalance and heightened cravings.
Research suggests moderate drinkers have healthier gut microbiomes. While red wine consumption may enhance gut diversity, similar benefits can be found in plant-based and fermented foods. Dysbiosis may worsen addiction, highlighting the need for holistic approaches to treatment.
